Lemoyne, PA  | 717-761-4712

Christian Baker Company - Insurance | Lemoyne, PA Linked-in Facebook Tammy McAllister Susie M. Wharton – Personal Lines Producer Malinda M. Kern – Senior Customer Service Representative
Alan W. Gallagher, CES, CBC Polly McGlynn Brendan Renne Brian D. Warner CPCU, CIC Debra Anderson James D. Pace

Christian-Baker Company has been providing cost effective and coverage rich insurance solutions to our clients since we were a 3-person agency. We have grown to over 20 employees, each committed to comprehensive insurance solutions and service to our clients. Call us at 717-761-4712 and request a FREE quote today.

Serving our clients, one at a time, since 1938

Check out our insurance services

Meet the members of our team

Contact us and we'll find you an insurance plan that suits your needs. Call us at


Owner of the Agency

Office personnel

Commercial lines department

Brian D. Warner CPCU, CIC – Commercial Producer


Brian has more than 25 years of experience in the insurance industry. Brian is a business graduate of Juniata College in Huntingdon Pennsylvania. His insurance education has been broadened by obtaining his CPCU (Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriter) and CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) designations. He started his career with insurance company, but has spent most of his years on the agency end of the business. Brian specializes in working with commercial business of all sizes but also writes life insurance and personal insurance to meet his client’s needs. His job is to find the best match for your company and Christian Baker’s group of over 40 insurance carriers. Brian strives to give his clients the service they deserve and is continually looking to find new clients.


Send Brian an email

Life and health department

Alan W. Gallagher, CES, CBC – Benefits Consultant


Mr. Gallagher began his career in insurance as a self-employed, independent insurance agent, initially concentrating on the sale of Voluntary Employee Benefits. Alan then expanded his portfolio of products and services to include group health insurance; and other employer paid benefits such as dental, vision, life, and disability insurances. Alan joined CBC in 2003 to manage its Life & Health Division, concentrating on helping the employer (group) market segment control the cost of employee benefits, while searching for cost effective ways to improve benefit plans. Alan has earned CES (Certified Enrollment Specialist) and CBC (Chartered Benefits Consultant) designation as well as being certified to sell Medicare insurance plans. He graduated from Penn State University with a Bachelor of Social Science Degree and is a retired U.S. Army Reserve Lieutenant Colonel.


Send Alan an email

Personal lines department

Susie M. Wharton – Personal Lines Producer


Susie has been part of the Christian Baker team since October of 2004. She is a licensed agent who specializes in writing home, auto, and umbrella policies. Having access to quote with numerous companies allows Susie to shop accounts, in an effort to get the best policy premiums. Her goal is to continue to provide exceptional customer service to all of her clients. She values not only her business relationships, but the personal relationships she has developed with her clients throughout the years.


Outside of work, Susie enjoys spending quality time with her family and friends. Her true happiness comes from being a Mother to her two small daughters. Whether you are looking for a new car or buying a new house or just interested in learning more about your insurance needs, please contact Susie for her expertise.


Send Susie an email

James D. Pace, CIC – President


Jim came to Christian-Baker Co. on January 1st, 1989 after working as an insurance agent in Marysville for 8 years. He started in the insurance business working with Life Insurance. He began selling auto and homeowners insurance and then quickly moved to commercial coverage. He came to Christian-Baker Co. to expand his ability to provide commercial coverage to a larger number of clients. Jim handles commercial insurance for a variety of clients. Jim also enjoys working with programs or special groups, such as the NWCOA and NWRA.


Send Jim an email

Debra Anderson – Claims Specialist


A graduate of Lebanon Valley College, Debra has been part of Christian-Baker Company since 1989. During that time, she has handled the claims for our personal and commercial lines clients and enjoys assisting them throughout the claims process. From first report to final resolution, Debra’s goal is complete customer satisfaction. Using a variety of skills, from expediting to mediating, and at times just patiently listening, she strives to help each client have a better claims experience. If you have a claim to report, or if you just have a claims-related question, Debra is here to help.


Send Deb an email

Brendan Renne – Commercial Producer


Brendan began his insurance career in 1999 with Penn National Insurance and transitioned to the agency side in 2003. His experience within the industry, and proven excellence in customer service, make him a valuable asset to the companies we represent and to the Christian-Baker agency. Brendan specializes in commercial property and casualty coverage including property, auto, general or professional liability, and workers’ compensation. Brendan is a 1998 graduate of the University of Pittsburgh.


Brendan’s goal as an insurance technician is to assist business owners in analyzing and better understanding their insurance needs and exposures.


Send Brendan an email

Jamie Myers – Commercial Producer


Jamie began her insurance career in 2001 in the financial industry. She then expanded into a management role for a BGA assisting producers and specializing client solutions in the areas of Life, LTC, Annuities and Disability Insurance. Her experience within the industry and proven excellence in providing customer solutions make her a valuable asset to the companies we represent and to the Christian Baker Company. Jamie obtained her property and casualty insurance license and joined the team in April of 2015 as a specialist in commercial property and casualty coverage including property, auto, general or professional liability, and workers compensation. Jamie is a 2010 graduate of Shippensburg University with a master’s degree in Organizational Development & Leadership.


Send Jamie an email

Polly McGlynn – Commercial Lines Service Manager


Polly began her insurance career, working at Bristol West as a claims assistant. She joined Christian Baker Company in March of 2003 and obtained her property and casualty insurance license in 2006. She works in the commercial lines department and is committed to providing great service to our customers. She works attentively to ensure our customer’s policies are accurate and in order.


Send Polly an email

Malinda M. Kern – Senior Customer Service Representative


Malinda has worked in the insurance industry for more than 27 years. Since Malinda joined the agency in 1990, she has specialized in fulfilling the needs of her customers. She will handle policy changes, certificates, billing, policy reviews and other services. Malinda has worked with many of our larger accounts and she is our Senior Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative.


Send Malinda an email

Tammy McAllister, CISR – Senior Customer Service Representative


Tammy has worked in the insurance industry for 17+ years servicing all premium sizes of commercial accounts. She currently holds the CISR (Certified Insurance Service Representative) designation. She currently resides in Mount Joy PA with her husband. Outside of work Tammy enjoys watching Penn State and EAGLES football and FLYERS hockey, working out and spending time with good friends and neighbors. Her goals for each insured… treat them all like VIP’s!

Jamiemyers Rob Fitzgerald, CIC – Commercial Producer

Rob Fitzgerald, CIC – Commercial Producer


Rob is a graduate of Penn State University. He has been involved in the insurance industry for over 13 years as a commercial agent. He holds the designation of Certified Insurance Counselor, which he has held since 2010.

He joined the Christian Baker team in 2016.


In his spare time, he likes to watch his sons play soccer and basketball. He also enjoys playing golf and traveling.


Rob takes pride in listening to his clients needs. For that reason, he tends to focus on larger operations that are more detailed in nature. His objective is to help clients design and implement insurance programs that work best for their operations.


Send Rob an Email

Julia Martello

Julia Martello – Personal Lines Producer


Julia became a part of the Christian-Baker team in May of 2017 as an intern working in the personal lines department and assisting in the Wildlife program. She is licensed in property and casualty insurance and is quickly learning about the industry. Julia proudly accepted a full time position in the personal lines department at Christian-Baker Company working alongside Susie Wharton. Her favorite part about working in the personal lines department is assisting and working closely with clients. Her goal is to earn clients trust by responding efficiently and effectively to their needs and helping in any way that she can.


Julia is a recent business administration graduate with minors in both Finance and Marketing from York College of Pennsylvania. In her down time, she enjoys spending time with her family, friends and riding her horse.

Joanne Krepps – Commercial Customer Service Representative

Joanne Krepps – Commercial Customer Service Representative


Joanne has worked in the insurance industry for more than 25 years. She has customer service experience from both insurance carriers and insurance agencies. Joanne will process policy changes, certificates, and renewals. Joanne works with our insurance carriers to ensure a quality product is issued to our customers. She enjoys speaking with and helping our customers with their service needs.


Send Joanne an email

Trey Minskey

Trey Minskey – Commercial Lines Producer


Trey joined the Christian-Baker team in March of 2018. Licensed in Property and Casualty, Trey aims to serve his clients through outstanding customer service and insurance knowledge by tailoring a comprehensive insurance plan for each customer. He also plays an integral role in working with the wildlife programs here at the agency.

Trey is a graduate of Bloomsburg University.  In his spare time he enjoys the outdoors, exercising, and time with family and friends.

Alison Mansfield  -- Commercial Customer Service Representative



Alison joined the Christian-Baker team in 2015.  She is licensed in property and casualty insurance, and works with Jim and Trey in the wildlife program.  She enjoys working closely with our clients, providing personalized customer service to everyone.


Alison is most proud of her four amazing, very involved daughters.  When not at work, Alison can be found at a soccer game, track meet, dance performance or football game watching her kids.  Nothing brings her more joy than watching her kids doing what they love.  If she’s not watching a sporting event, she can be found on her family’s alpaca farm, helping with the animals. She enjoys spending time with family and friends and being outdoors.

Alison Mansfield